Which Island is better: Saona or Catalina?
If you’re planning a tropical escape to the Dominican Republic, you’ve probably heard of two island gems: Saona and Catalina. Both offer stunning beaches, crystal-clear waters, and unforgettable adventures — but each has its own personality. So, how do you decide which island is best for you? Whether you’re a beach lover, a snorkeling enthusiast, or looking for a unique local experience, this guide will help you choose between Saona and Catalina. Let’s dive into the highlights of both!
The scenery: postcard-perfect views
Saona Island is famous for its endless stretch of white sandy beaches lined with palm trees. It’s the kind of landscape you see on postcards or screensavers — wide, open, and dreamy.
Catalina Island, on the other hand, feels a bit more rugged and wild. Its coastline is rockier, and the beaches are smaller but intimate, often surrounded by lush vegetation and dramatic cliffs.
The snorkeling experience
For underwater lovers, Catalina takes the lead. Its marine biodiversity is unmatched in the region, especially at the famous “The Wall” and “Aquarium” snorkeling sites. The coral reefs are vibrant and full of life.
Saona also offers snorkeling, especially in the shallow natural pool where you can spot starfish. But the marine life isn’t quite as rich or diverse as Catalina.
Atmosphere and crowd
Saona is the more popular of the two islands, meaning it’s often more crowded, especially during high season. Nevertheless, you will enjoy a quieter private beach with Quetzal Excursons. We offers exclusive access to a spot away from the crowds, a peaceful landscape just for you.
Catalina is generally quieter and more laid-back, ideal for couples, families, or travelers looking for something a little less touristy and more intimate.
Travel time and accessibility
Saona is further from the mainland, usually requiring a longer boat ride, but the trip includes stunning stops during the day.
Catalina is closer and faster to reach, especially from Bayahibe, making it a great option for those wanting a shorter journey but still a full island day.
Family vs adventure: who’s it for?
Choose Saona if you’re traveling with children or want a balanced mix of relaxation, fun, and light exploration. The shallow waters and beach facilities make it very family-friendly.
Pick Catalina if you’re an adventure-seeker or a passionate snorkeler. Its marine life is a major draw, and the excursions tend to feel more “off the beaten path.”
Final consideration and our advice
If it’s your first time in the Dominican Republic and you want the classic Caribbean beach day, Saona might be the perfect fit.
But if you’ve already been to Saona — or you prefer a more authentic and underwater-focused trip — Catalina is the hidden gem worth discovering !
With Quetzal Excursions, you can’t go wrong: both islands are experienced aboard our sailing catamaran, with personalized service, small group sizes, and a crew that loves sharing the best of the Dominican Republic.
Conclusion
So… Saona or Catalina?
It really depends on what you’re looking for. Saona brings the iconic tropical dream, while Catalina surprises you with its underwater beauty and calm charm. Either way, your day will be filled with sunshine, turquoise water, and unforgettable memories. Whichever you choose, we’re here to make it magical !
Who are we?
Based in Bayahibe, Quetzal Excursions is a local agency specialized in small-group sea trips to Saona, Catalina, and the most beautiful hidden gems of the Dominican Republic. We focus on comfort, safety, and authenticity, aboard high-end boats with a professional crew.
📱 CONTACT US ON WHATSAPP : +1 (809) 979-7359
Our Regular Excursions
Saona by Catamaran – All Comfort
Buggy and Quad tour - Sunset Special
Our Excursion to Catalina Island
Snorkeling Tour to Catalina
Our Private Excursions
Private rental of the Quetzal catamaran
📌 Need help planning your excursion?
Contact Quetzal Excursions to plan your activities from your place of stay, with included transport, small group, professional guide, and high-end services.